Anonymous cardinal breaks conclave secrecy

A member of the College of Cardinals has given a detailed description of the conclave that elected Pope Benedict XVI, confirming that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was elected on the fourth ballot, and his main rival was Argentine Jesuit, Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio.

CLICK HERECatholic World News reports that the cardinal also provided the results of that ballot, saying that Cardinal Ratzinger won 84 votes, with 26 for Cardinal Bergoglio.

In an evening news program that aired on Thursday, RAI television reported that the cardinal had given a full account of the papal election to the Italian journal Limes, confirming much of what Vatican-watchers had already concluded.

At the start of a papal conclave, all of the cardinal-electors swear a solemn oath to preserve the absolute secrecy of the proceedings. But journalists had previously persuaded some prelates to offer a few clues about the proceedings.

In an article entitled "How we elected Pope Ratzinger," journalist Lucio Brunelli presents what he claims is an eyewitness account, furnished by an anonymous cardinal, of the 2-day conclave that took place on 18 and 19 April.

Catholic World News comments that it is impossible to determine the accuracy of the account presented by Limes, suggesting that is may even be a hoax.

"If it is indeed the account of a cardinal who participated in the conclave, the credibility of this eyewitness is severely undermined by his willingness to violate his oath. Still, sources at the Vatican note that the details of the story seem to match all of the available evidence about the conclave."

The Limes account does contradict less detailed leaks from conclave participants that suggested Cardinal Martini was the main rival to Cardinal Ratzinger during the conclave. According to the anonymous cardinal cited by Limes, the former Archbishop of Milan never won more than 9 votes.

Unknown cardinal breaks secrecy, describes conclave (Catholic World News 23/9/05)

LINKS (not necessarily endorsed by Church Resources)
Limes Online - Archive

Pope Benedict elected after Argentine waiver-report (Reuters 23/9/05)
Pope elected after rival backed away: report (ABC News 24/9/05)
Be a Nurse for a day draws keen student interest (Australian Catholic University 23/9/05)
The Pope's Angelus address: "Imitate Mother Teresa, an example of active and often heroic charity" (AsiaNews.it 24/9/05)
Article based on diary says German cardinal became pope with 84 votes (Catholic News Service 23/9/05)
Pope defends Mexican Catholics' rights to be involved in politics (Catholic News Service 23/9/05)
Seamless web: providing papal security with reasonable public access (Catholic News Service 23/9/05)
Pope Benedict to Mexican Bishops: faith shouldn't be reduced to private sphere (Catholic News Agency 23/9/05)
In true democracies, says Pope, religious freedom can, must exist (Catholic News Agency 23/9/05)
Pope tells Mexican bishops: minister to everyone, the faithful and the searching; give greatest attention to priests (Catholic News Agency 23/9/05)
Cardinal decries breach of conclave secrecy (Catholic World News 23/9/05)
Protect religious freedom, Pope urges Mexican government (Catholic World News 23/9/05)
Pope Benedict Gives First TV Interview (Leading the Charge 22/9/05)
Benedict chosen after Argentine declined (The Age 24/9/05)
Pope John Paul II "not a martyr" (The Universe 25/9/05)
Vatican: Back to Business (Vatican Radio English Features 25/9/05, audio - requires Real Player)
Benedict XVI Receives President of Malawi (Zenit 22/9/05)
Freedom Needed to Give Religious Sense to State, Says Pope (Zenit 23/9/05)
Benedict XVI Grants 1st TV Interview to Poland (Zenit 23/9/05)

26 Sep 2005